Reyes/Garza for Cain/Pence?

[guyincognito]

I've just been offered the following deal:

I give: J.Reyes, M.Garza and J.Frasor
I get: M.Cain, H.Pence

I could use the pitching help, don't know how much I need Pence. Seems like a decent deal, just not sure if I should pull the trigger?

12 team, H2H, Keeper league (keep 3)
H cats: H, R, HR, RBI, SB, K, Avg, OPS, E
P cats: W, SV, HD, K, BB, HA, QS, ERA, WHIP

C - B.Molina
1B - Pujols
2B - A.Hill
3B - ARod
SS - Reyes
OF - Sizemore, Quentin, Ludwick
Util - Vlad
Bench - Magglio, K.Johnson, M.Tejada
DL - Beltran
SP - Verlander
SP - Vazquez
RP - Fuentes
RP - Jenks
P - Madson
P - Guerrier
P - Frasor
Bench - Garza, Lilly, J.Sanchez
DL - H.Street

[Bosny]

Not sure I like this deal for you. I like Garza a lot this year and don;t think Cain is that huge of an uphrade. Reyes when healthy is much better than Pence. I say stay put, enjoy a great year from Garza and watch reyes climb back up to a solid SS. Good luck.

[RedBirdChica]

I don't think the deal helps you all that much. If you cut the fat out of the deal, what you're really looking at is Reyes for Cain.

You're not getting a SS with upside in return, so you'd have to put an inconsistent Tejada in your everyday lineup.

Pence is a decent 4/5 OF, but not proving to be much better than some of the guys who can be picked up off of the wire.

I concur with the post above; Garza (who was very unlucky last year) has more upside than Cain. Stay where you are.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=407555

[Darth Danielus]

I might prefer cain a bit to garza.....maybe. But whatever the gap in value is, the rest of the deal swings too far in the other guy's direction.

Pass.