Billy Butler for Justin Upton....Need Help!

[amackie]

My corner infielders: B. Butler, C. Pena, J. Peralta, M. Reynolds, K. Morales.
My Outfield: T. Hunter, H. Pence, R. Davis, C. Ross, J. Willingham, D. Fowler.

Should I do this deal. I have been sitting Pena and playing Reynolds, Morales, Butler (peralta at Middle INfielder).

Help Please

[ROC AllStars]

Yes, immediately. Billy Butler has a lot of upside, but his potential is easily dwarfed by Upton in every category, in every format. IMO Upton is more valuable than Butler in both redraft and keeper leagues.

Good luck!

Help if you can:
viewtopic.php?t=407510

[cwrtlm]

You should have accepted that a long time ago. Upton way better than Buttler in every aspect.

Help me:
viewtopic.php?t=407515

[Kimbos Beard]

Pull the trigger immediately. Butler is nice but Justin Upton is a top 20 player. Its a great move for you.