Carmona vs. Duchscherer--WHIR

[bearsfreak]

Head 2 Head matchup--choice between 2 start pitchers Carmona or Duchscherer. I saw ESPN had Duch way up on Carmona in the rankings, but it doesn't seem like the matchups are so significantly different, and based on their spring trainings and first starts, why wouldn't Carmona be a better bet?

[Hes So Taguchi]

Carmona needs to prove himself to be rosterable before you take a shot at him.

I had him off the wires and played him in his first start and then promptly traded him in a package. 6 walks is horrible and he never strikes out anyone. I'd say sit on him until he has a decent start or two where he actually shows some control of his pitches.