Blockbuster Hanley Trade

[rasto21585]

I just received an offer where I trade morneau bj upton howie kendrick and ryan theriot for hanley chris coghlan mark derosa and mat gamel. I think this is a solid offer, but I somehow feel that I am getting the short end of the stick in this trade. What do you all think?

20 team h2h dynasty league

c russel martin
1b justin morneau
2b howie kendrick
3b chase headly
ss ryan theriot
if blake dewitt
lf carlos lee
cf colby rasmus
rf justin upton
of ryan ludwick
util bj upton
bn fucodome
bn jesus montero
bn alex avila

sp jon lester
sp cole hamels
sp homer bailey
rp rafael soriano
rp colby lewis
rp dustin nippert
p ryan rowland smith
p doug fister
p c.j. wilson
bn felipe paulino
bn charlie haegar
bn geo gonzalez

[rasto21585]

anyone?

[Grounded Polo]

Getting the 2nd best player in fantasy without giving up any top 35 players sounds good to me.

[rasto21585]

do you think i would lose some useful depth with this trade?

[HueyntheNews]

I guarantee that there are 1st baseman out there who will be within 3-4 pts of morneau's weekly totals who you could get for a lot less. Hanley is invaluable. You are getting the best player in the deal, hands down. If you want you might consider countering with an offer that includes a slightly better OF for BJ Upton, but tbh, I'd do this.

[rasto21585]

Fwi this is part of a 3 way trade. I would first trade morneau and bj upton for miguel cabrera and chris coghlan. Then I would trade miguel cabrera, howie kendrick and ryan theriot for hanley, mark derosa and mat gamel.

[marqptm]

Do it. You're only really losing Upton and gaining a lot.

[rookies and cream]

Getting the 2nd best player in fantasy without giving up any top 35 players sounds good to me.

Agree with this.

Help with mine.

viewtopic.php?t=407459

[rasto21585]

Does the dropoff of the players I am trading away big enough for me to this deal?

[The Artful Dodger]

I think you lose a bit of depth in the Miggy trade, but I would take that deal. I don't really think you're missing anything with Kendrick/Theriot if you swing Miggy for Hanley (I'd make the Hanley deal as well).