Hill/Lackey for Jeter/Billingsley

[suppasonic]

16-Team DYNASTY (keep all players year to year)
Batting Stats: R 2B 3B HR RBI K SB AVG OPS
Pitching: IP HR K CG W SV HD ERA WHIP

C: McCann
1B: Miguel Cabrera
2B: Kelly Johnson (See Below)
3B: Mark Reynolds
SS: Derek Jeter
OF: Lastings Milledge
OF: Grady Sizemore
OF: Justin Upton
UTIL: Carlos Pena
BN: Gordon Beckham (See Below)
BN: Alexei Ramirez
BN: Chris Young


SP: Billinglsey
SP: Kershaw
RP: Soria
RP: Frasor
P: Coffey
P: Wainwright
P: Jon Sanchez
BN: Hamels
BN: Beckett
BN: Matusz
BN: Belisario

So, I have a bit of a Middle Infield Logjam. I obvisouly cant start both Alexei and Jeter so I'm trying to trade Jeter. My initial preseason plan was to move Beckham to 2B (thus his bench status), but now I can either move Pena or Reynolds.
The swap between Bills and Lackey is obviously pretty close with Lackey slightly better but also older/more injury prone.

Thanks cafe, I always love your help!!!