Utley/CGon/Bruce for McCutch/Ells/Beckham

[Chicago 2]

Y! 12 Team
Auction League
Normal Stats and Rosters (1 Util Spot)

Getting:
Andrew McCutcheon
Jacoby Ellsbury
Gordon Beckham

Giving:
Chase Utley
Carlos Gonzalez
Jay Bruce

My Team:

C Mike Napoli
1B Billy Butler
2B Chase Utley
3B Evan Longoria
SS Troy Tulowitzki
OF Grady Sizemore
OF Nelson Cruz
OF Carlos Gonzalez
Util Jay Bruce
BN Magglio Ordonez
BN Ian Desmond
BN Kyle Blanks

Utley apparently a hot commodity, other day I was offered Dunn and Roberts for him. This one is interesting, thoughts?

[joe112]

NO!!!!!! Do Not Do This Trade. You are getting hosed.

[Chicago 2]

NO!!!!!! Do Not Do This Trade. You are getting hosed.

I'm not a big fan of the deal but steals is a need for me and some good potential players.

[oddmanout7]

I would pass on this deal. If you need steals maybe pickup a guy like Brett Gardner?

[ar0d422]

do not do that trade!!!

[ar0d422]

dont do the one for roberts either. and please post all ur trades on here because if you thought that trade was fair your going to get taken advantage of

[Chicago 2]

dont do the one for roberts either. and please post all ur trades on here because if you thought that trade was fair your going to get taken advantage of

My first year doing a money league so there is some hesitation, fantasy vet and I usually do well. Just getting a second opinion, my initial reaction was to reject but always curious to get other responses.

[Rance Mulliniks]

I honestly think you're getting fleeced. I understand the argument that if Ellsbury steals 70 he's a hot fantasy stud, but I still see him as one dimensional. You're giving up a 1st rounder (Utley) and not getting anywhere near comparable talent back.

To throw it back to you, what are you thinking on this deal? Why does it seem right for you??