H.Ramirez & C.Davis for M.Kemp & M.Reynolds?

[Dr.Noisewater]

Received an offer of his Hanley Ramirez and Chris Davis for my Matt Kemp and Mark Reynolds.

Thoughts? Good trade to get the top pick?

My team is as follows:

C Kurt Suzuki, Oak C Sea
1B Miguel Cabrera, Det 1B
2B Robinson Cano, NYY 2B
3B Ian Stewart, Col 2B, 3B
SS Miguel Tejada, Bal SS
OF Matt Kemp, LAD OF
OF Nelson Cruz, Tex OF
OF Curtis Granderson, NYY OF
UTIL Mark Reynolds, Ari 3B, 1B
UTIL Carlos Gonzalez, Col OF
Bench Alexei Ramirez, CWS SS
Bench Vernon Wells, Tor OF
Bench Ryan Ludwick, StL OF

PITCHERS
P Josh Johnson, Fla SP
P Tommy Hanson, Atl SP PP
P Jake Peavy, CWS SP
P Billy Wagner, Atl RP
P Mike Gonzalez, Bal RP
Bench Cole Hamels, Phi SP
Bench Ted Lilly*, ChC SP DL15
DL Scott Kazmir*, LAA SP DL15

[Dr.Noisewater]

Forgot to add it is a 12-team standard Rotisserie league.

[802GREENS]

I like this trade for you. DO IT!

Help with mine? viewtopic.php

[ar0d422]

Deffinately do it.

help me out
viewtopic.php?t=407008

[Padres Fan]

the 2nd best player in baseball for a top 5 OF and probably 20th best fanatsy plyer, plu Davis and Reynolds should produce the same in average and homers, but reynolds gets more steals, I would do it

[The Artful Dodger]

It's an OK deal. It's a tad on the steep side, but then again, it's for Hanley after all and worth doing. Only thing to worry about is Davis could be platooned especially against LHP and I don't necessarily think he's a perfect substitute for Reynolds, especially if he piles on the K's and the leash is shorter for him.

I think you should try shopping Alexei and you're good to go.

[Darth Danielus]

I like it.

[j24jags]

I would not make this trade. I am a big Kemp fan, and I think he and Hanley will be comparable in HRs/Rs/RBIs. Hanley may hit 10 points higher, but Kemp may swipe a few more bags (he will be in the 2-hole a lot whereas Hanley will be in the 3-hole). Yes Hanley is the better player, but Reynolds will get much more ABs than Davis (looks like Garko is starting over Davis vs LHPs), and Reynolds has shown that he can hit 40 HRs while Davis is still a question mark to hit 25.

viewtopic.php?t=407026