Chase Utley for Brian Roberts/Adam Dunn

[Chicago 2]

12 Team Yahoo
Auction League
Normal Stat Categories and Rosters (1 Util Spot)

Getting:
Brian Roberts
Adam Dunn

Giving:
Chase Utley

Team:

C Mike Napoli
1B Billy Butler
2B Chase Utley
3B Evan Longoria
SS Troy Tulowitzki
OF Grady Sizemore
OF Nelson Cruz
OF Carlos Gonzalez
Util Jay Bruce
BN Magglio Ordonez
BN Kyle Blanks
BN Ian Desmond

Thoughts, doesn't seem to bad for me but too early?

[ar0d422]

I would not do this trade. Roberts is not going to be as good this year. Dunn gets way to many K's and your team already has a lot of K's. Utley is a Stud. Try trading with someone else.

help me out
viewtopic.php?t=406865

[sappisgod]

Yeah, I think you can get more for someone of Utley's production/position/lineup. If you're looking for an upgrade at 1st, you can do better than Dunn w/Utley. I'd go after a team with a cheaper 2B in the vein of Uggla, so that you could get more value out of the other bat you pick up. Something like Votto/Uggla or A-Gon/Uggla and the like.

viewtopic.php?t=406866

[Kimbos Beard]

The value part isn't bad, but I don't see how it really benefits your team. I think your team is strong enough as it is on offense.

I would hold off and see how your team develops. Usually you would do 2 for 1 when you need to add quantity, but I dont see that as a problem right now.

[onitapgr]

No, it wouldnt be worth benching one of your other players to play Dunn.....

Maybe if Roberts is doing well in a month or two and has no injury setbacks.....try for Roberts and an ace....

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=29&t=406855

[ar0d422]

No, it wouldnt be worth benching one of your other players to play Dunn.....

Maybe if Roberts is doing well in a month or two and has no injury setbacks.....try for Roberts and an ace....

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=29&t=406855

i wouldnt go for robets

[dagactor]

No no no. Utley is a top 5. Roberts is injuredish (and we draft him for running...so scary) and Dunn has a bad avg.