Am I overvaluing Josh Beckett?

[Mateo de Lorenzo]

So, I am stacked at SP and willing to trade one. Josh Beckett has proven to garner the most interest but I have been unhappy with the trade offers.

I was offered Andre Ethier for Beckett straight up. Ethier is a stud, but I still think Beckett is worth a little more.

I was offered Josh Hamilton for Beckett straight up. Maybe this is more me undervaluing Josh Hamilton because I admit I am not very high on the guy, but it still seems like a low end offer.

I was offered Chris Perez and Carlos Santana which I laughed at. I need RP help, but this deal wasn't gonna happen

Am I overvaluing Beckett for wanting more than Ethier or Hamilton straight up? Would a Zobrist for Beckett straight up be fair, assuming my counter offer were considered?

[ar0d422]

Post your roster, its easier to help that way...


should i trade pujos for more pitching?
viewtopic.php?t=406751

[thejusman1]

Going just off ADP, Beckett for Zobrist would be a great deal for you, and Beckett for Ethier or Hamilton are pretty fair, if not slightly in your favor. Beckett is solid, but those guys are solid hitters as well. Guys who have the potential to go .300-100-30-100 don't grow on trees...

[Mateo de Lorenzo]

C Kurt Suzuki
1B James Loney
2B Dan Uggla
3B Jorge Cantu
SS Alcides Escobar
MI Asdrubal Escobar
CI Michael Cuddyer
OF Ryan Braun
OF Carl Crawford
OF Rajai Davis
OF Will Venable
OF Jason Werth
U Placido Polanco

BN: Chris Ianetta

P Josh Beckett
P Brett Anderson
P Mark Buehrle
P Edwin Jackson
P Mat Latos
P Vicente Padilla
P Jonathan Broxton
P Andrew Bailey
P George Sherrill

BN: Joel Pineiro, David Price

[Mateo de Lorenzo]

Post your roster, its easier to help that way...


should i trade pujos for more pitching?
viewtopic.php?t=406751

Posted as reply. Thanks.

[angels7777]

I would not trade Beckett for Hamilton (injuries for sure) - and I would take Beckett personally over Ethier

if you think Zobrist can repeat last year, that deal is more reasonable... so I do not think you are overvaluing Beckett - I just think every team tends to overvalue their own individual players generally

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=406537

[sreill]

I wouldnt accept any of those offers either..