Which 3B Should I Run With?

[Special_Delivery]

Hey guys I'm in a 12 team 5x5 standard non-keeper league. It was an autodraft which killed my 3B situation by drafting Alex Gordon. I initially swapped him out for Chris Davis, but I'm thinking his avg is going to drain my team so I switched to Garrett Atkins. I hate taking players in decline, so do you feel any of these available players are better? Should I run a platoon with any of them or make a trade? Thanks for the input~

FAs: Juan Uribe, Chase Headley, Chris Davis, Casey McGehee, Scott Rolen, Kevin Kouzmanoff, Edwin Encarnacion, David Freese.

My team:
C: Napoli
1B: Pujols, Loney
2B: Zobrist
3B: Atkins
SS: Reyes, A. Escobar
OF: Upton, Sizemore, McCutchen, Ramirez, Ordonez
SP: Gallardo, Shields, Oswalt, Garza, Wolf, Marcum, Liriano
RP: Soriano, Dotel, Capps, Perez
DL: Berkman

[ar0d422]

Hey guys I'm in a 12 team 5x5 standard non-keeper league. It was an autodraft which killed my 3B situation by drafting Alex Gordon. I initially swapped him out for Chris Davis, but I'm thinking his avg is going to drain my team so I switched to Garrett Atkins. I hate taking players in decline, so do you feel any of these available players are better? Should I run a platoon with any of them or make a trade? Thanks for the input~

FAs: Juan Uribe, Chase Headley, Chris Davis, Casey McGehee, Scott Rolen, Kevin Kouzmanoff, Edwin Encarnacion, David Freese.

My team:
C: Napoli
1B: Pujols, Loney
2B: Zobrist
3B: Atkins
SS: Reyes, A. Escobar
OF: Upton, Sizemore, McCutchen, Ramirez, Ordonez
SP: Gallardo, Shields, Oswalt, Garza, Wolf, Marcum, Liriano
RP: Soriano, Dotel, Capps, Perez
DL: Berkman

this is pretty funny because I just posted the same question with the same players earlier today. I ended up going with Headley. But the advice I got from everyone else was 50% Headley 50% Casy McGehee.

Help me out should i trade pujos?
viewtopic.php?t=406751

[Special_Delivery]

Haha man I didn't even look at the topics before I posted, that's my fault. Thanks for the response.