Who should I pick between these 5 players for 3B!!!

[ar0d422]

Chase Headley
Casey McGehee
Blake DeWitt
Juan Uribe
Brandon Inge

this is my team

I kinda of also want to pick up carmona. Right now I have 1 empty spot on my roster, but who should I drop to pick up carmona?

Jorge Posada
1B
Albert Pujols
2B
Aaron Hill
3B
Empty at the moment (because I want to pick up Street because some idoit dropped him instead of putting him in the DL spot). Going to put sandoval here, Helton to 1st and tejada at IF
SS
Erick Aybar
IF
Todd Helton
LF
Matt Holliday
CF
Jacoby Ellsbury
RF
Nick Markakis
OF
Bobby Abreu
Util
Hideki Matsui
BN
Miguel Tejada
BN





Ricky Nolasco
SP
A.J. Burnett
SP
James Shields
RP
Francisco Rodriguez
RP
Brian Wilson
P
Jonathan Sanchez
P
Trevor Hoffman
P
Franklin Morales
BN
Jorge De La Rosa
BN
Aroldis Chapman
BN
Wade Davis
BN
Brian Matusz
DL
Houston Street

[ar0d422]

bump... help please

[ar0d422]

helppp

[thejusman1]

I'm probably grabbing McGahee here... although I'd keep a close eye on DeWitt and Headley too. Headley's a top prospect, but has been a disappointment thus far. If he starts getting hot, I might make that switch. DeWitt profiles similarly, but he's at even worse disadvantage because he might be platooned sometime during the season against lefties. Juan Uribe and Inge are non-factors for me here.

[Surfs up]

Headley

[ar0d422]

I'm probably grabbing McGahee here... although I'd keep a close eye on DeWitt and Headley too. Headley's a top prospect, but has been a disappointment thus far. If he starts getting hot, I might make that switch. DeWitt profiles similarly, but he's at even worse disadvantage because he might be platooned sometime during the season against lefties. Juan Uribe and Inge are non-factors for me here.

thanks man

[mjoyce103]

I agree with McGehee, but I'd pay extra attention to Headley. If he strings together a couple nice games it could be an indication that he's starting to break out a bit, and of all the guys he has the most upside.

[plapre3]

I'd go with Headley, espeically if you think you can platoon him with someone to take advantage of his road/ home splits. The usual caveats with spring stats apply, but he did lead everyone in RBI this spring and I think we can expect more of that to come. He's hitting in front of A-Gon and hit .305/ .377/ .426 away from Petco last year. Throw in the fact that he has pedigree of a good prospect and it's not a stretch to think that he might be on the verge of a breakout.

Please help:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=406707

[HldOnMgnolia]

Grab Headley.

Leave Carmona.