Rollins for Zimmerman

[bujfan2030]

13 team, 21 player(C,1B,2B,SS,3B,3OF,Util,2SP,2RP,3P)5x5 roto keeper league(7 players)
Trying to improve my power so
I offered Jimmy Rollins for Ryan Zimmerman
He's countered with Zimmerman and Matt Thornton for Rollins and Brian Fuentes

He's got Wright at 3rd and Aybar at short. His only other reliever is Hoffman. My only other relievers are Rauch and Guerrier. I'm afraid if i make this trade, as is, I'll be punting saves. Was my original offer fair. Most rankings I've seen have Rollins ranked ahead of Zimmerman. I know Rollins value is slightly inflated but I still haven't seen anything where Zimmerman's ranked higher except of course last years final rankings. But all the projections I've seen have Rollins average bouncing back this year. Does the fact that it's a Keper league make Zimmerman more valuable. And if so Could I get away just offering Rauch.

[mak1277]

who do you have right now at 3b? Who would you replace Rollins with at SS if you made the trade?

[sKooch]

What does your roster look like? All depends on who you can replace with...

[jdip5]

in terms of raw number, zimmerman will be ranked higher then rollisn this year hands down

[bujfan2030]

C: Matt Wieters(K)
1B: Lance Berkman(K)DL Using Todd Helton
2B : Brandon Phillips(K)
3B: Chipper Jones(2.11)
SS: Jimmy Rollins(K)
OF: Justin Upton(K)
OF: Morgan Nyjer
OF: Jason Heyward(3.3)
UTIL: Ben Zobrist(K)
SP: Josh Beckett(K)
SP: Ricky Nolasco(1.3)
RP: Brian Fuentes(5.03)
RP: Jon Rauch
P: Ryan Dempster(4.11)
P: Johnny Cueto
P: Mark Beurhle
Bench: Garrett Jones
Bench: Chase Headly
Bench: Matt Guerrier
Bench: Gio Gonzalez
Bench:Colby Lewis

Would move Zobrist to SS

[mak1277]

If you're set on moving Rollins for more power, I would try and get a bigger upgrade. Reality is that you're trading off 30+ SBs and 20 points of average for only about 10-12 more homers. I don't have a huge problem with Rollins for Zimmerman straight up, but I wouldn't give up Fuentes in the deal also.