Pujos and Franklin Morales for beckett Sandoval Rivera!!!!

[ar0d422]

The trade is Pujos and franklin morales (i just picked him up 2 days ago) for Beckett, Sandoval, Rivera.

This is a 12 team, 5 player keeper league

I feel like I need a better pitching staff. Also I am about to pick up Street and put him on my DL list until hes back.

Is this trade worth trading Pujos?

This is my team...


Jorge Posada
1B
Albert Pujols
2B
Aaron Hill
3B
Empty at the moment (because I want to pick up Street because some idoit dropped him instead of putting him in the DL spot). Going to put sandoval here, Helton to 1st and tejada at IF
SS
Erick Aybar
IF
Todd Helton
LF
Matt Holliday
CF
Jacoby Ellsbury
RF
Nick Markakis
OF
Bobby Abreu
Util
Hideki Matsui
BN
Miguel Tejada
BN





Ricky Nolasco
SP
A.J. Burnett
SP
James Shields
RP
Francisco Rodriguez
RP
Brian Wilson
P
Jonathan Sanchez
P
Trevor Hoffman
P
Franklin Morales
BN
Jorge De La Rosa
BN
Aroldis Chapman
BN
Wade Davis
BN
Brian Matusz

[slackgolf]

I think you could get more for Pujols, although your third base spot being empty is a big no no.

Pujols lovers will overpay and give you more.

Now help me viewtopic.php?f=29&t=406554

[ar0d422]

I just dropped casey McGehee b/c i wanted to pick up street and put him on my DL. I think it will be worth it to not have a player at 3b for 2 days... Anyway. I just picked up morales 2 days ago. So basically im trading pujos for all 3 of them. I have been trying to do other trades, but this was the best so far. I have been offered Wright and Victor Martinez for Pujos and yadiear molina. How much more do you think I can get?

[ar0d422]

more opinions pleasee.

Giving up Pujos is so hard. The kid im trying to trade with also has Halladay, but hes not willing to give up as much if he gives me Halladay instead of beckett.

[slackgolf]

I just dropped casey McGehee b/c i wanted to pick up street and put him on my DL. I think it will be worth it to not have a player at 3b for 2 days... Anyway. I just picked up morales 2 days ago. So basically im trading pujos for all 3 of them. I have been trying to do other trades, but this was the best so far. I have been offered Wright and Victor Martinez for Pujos and yadiear molina. How much more do you think I can get?

I dont take Saves much into consideration when it comes to this kind of trade just because you seem to have the RP depth to not need Rivera.

Beckett is good and Sandoval is a great player, but Pujols is the best in the game. You are giving up a lot of Power here and not getting much back. (40+ hrs easy for AP vs 20+ hrs in PS) You dont seem to have much power on your team and therefore It would need to be a blow away deal for me to give up AP. If it was Halladay Sandoval and maybe a decent OF then I would probably make the trade but unless its a top 5 pitcher and PS then I dont think you should pull the trigger.

Check out mine viewtopic.php?f=29&t=406554

[coma]

Thanks for the help? I was asking which of the 3 was best.. Thought I was pretty clear, but guess not.
This is not enough for Pujols. Stay put unless you get a 1st or 2nd round talent in return. I'm guessing you mean Mariano and not Juan?

[ar0d422]

I just dropped casey McGehee b/c i wanted to pick up street and put him on my DL. I think it will be worth it to not have a player at 3b for 2 days... Anyway. I just picked up morales 2 days ago. So basically im trading pujos for all 3 of them. I have been trying to do other trades, but this was the best so far. I have been offered Wright and Victor Martinez for Pujos and yadiear molina. How much more do you think I can get?

I dont take Saves much into consideration when it comes to this kind of trade just because you seem to have the RP depth to not need Rivera.

Beckett is good and Sandoval is a great player, but Pujols is the best in the game. You are giving up a lot of Power here and not getting much back. (40+ hrs easy for AP vs 20+ hrs in PS) You dont seem to have much power on your team and therefore It would need to be a blow away deal for me to give up AP. If it was Halladay Sandoval and maybe a decent OF then I would probably make the trade but unless its a top 5 pitcher and PS then I dont think you should pull the trigger.

Check out mine viewtopic.php?f=29&t=406554

I like having the best RP's. If I picked up Rivera, then I would have 5 BEAST RP's (including street). Most will pitch twice a week on average. Thats a good amount of Innings and helps lower the era and raise k/9. What do you think?

[ar0d422]

Thanks for the help? I was asking which of the 3 was best.. Thought I was pretty clear, but guess not.
This is not enough for Pujols. Stay put unless you get a 1st or 2nd round talent in return. I'm guessing you mean Mariano and not Juan?

yes mariano

[slackgolf]

I like having the best RP's. If I picked up Rivera, then I would have 5 BEAST RP's (including street). Most will pitch twice a week on average. Thats a good amount of Innings and helps lower the era and raise k/9. What do you think?[/quote]

I still dont like it for you. Pujols is worth much more, hold onto him for a bit and soon enough the trades will be coming in, or if someone has a good 1B that goes down then you can try and pry away an ace and a good hitter from them for Pujols. Beckett Sandoval Rivera is not enough to get rid of Pujols. I am not a fan of giving up the best player in the deal for 3 guys who should fall between rounds 5 and 8 for the clear cut 1st pick.

check out mine...viewtopic.php?f=29&t=406554

[ar0d422]

I just dropped casey McGehee b/c i wanted to pick up street and put him on my DL. I think it will be worth it to not have a player at 3b for 2 days... Anyway. I just picked up morales 2 days ago. So basically im trading pujos for all 3 of them. I have been trying to do other trades, but this was the best so far. I have been offered Wright and Victor Martinez for Pujos and yadiear molina. How much more do you think I can get?

I dont take Saves much into consideration when it comes to this kind of trade just because you seem to have the RP depth to not need Rivera.

Beckett is good and Sandoval is a great player, but Pujols is the best in the game. You are giving up a lot of Power here and not getting much back. (40+ hrs easy for AP vs 20+ hrs in PS) You dont seem to have much power on your team and therefore It would need to be a blow away deal for me to give up AP. If it was Halladay Sandoval and maybe a decent OF then I would probably make the trade but unless its a top 5 pitcher and PS then I dont think you should pull the trigger.

Check out mine viewtopic.php?f=29&t=406554

why would I want an OF. Look at my team, my OF is amazing. Im thinking halladay sandoval and some one else but not an OF.

This is his team...



Joe Mauer
(Min - C) No new player Notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ @LAA L, 6-3 98% 191/523 94 132 30 1 28 96 4 76 63 .365 1.031
1B
Pablo Sandoval
(SF - 1B,3B) Player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ @Hou W, 5-2 96% 189/572 79 115 44 5 25 90 5 52 83 .330 .943
2B
Alberto Callaspo
(KC - 2B,3B) New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List x Det L, 8-4 15% 173/576 79 113 41 8 11 73 2 52 51 .300 .813
3B
Scott Rolen
(Cin - 3B) New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ StL L, 11-6 12% 145/475 76 97 36 1 11 67 5 45 62 .305 .823
SS
Derek Jeter
(NYY - SS) Player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List 76% 212/634 107 166 27 1 18 66 30 72 90 .334 .871
IF
Adam Dunn
(Was - 1B,LF,RF) New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ Phi L, 11-1 90% 146/546 81 79 29 0 38 105 0 116 177 .267 .927
LF
Jason Bay
(NYM - LF) New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ Fla W, 7-1 96% 142/531 103 74 29 3 36 119 13 94 162 .267 .921
CF
Michael Bourn
(Hou - CF) No new player Notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ SF L, 5-2 75% 173/606 97 131 27 12 3 35 61 63 140 .285 .738
RF
Jason Kubel
(Min - LF,RF) No new player Notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ @LAA L, 6-3 75% 154/514 73 89 35 2 28 103 1 56 106 .300 .908
OF
Nyjer Morgan
(Was - LF,CF) New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ Phi L, 11-1 54% 144/469 74 119 15 7 3 39 42 40 74 .307 .757
Util
Billy Butler
(KC - 1B) New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ Det L, 8-4 79% 183/608 78 110 51 1 21 93 1 58 103 .301 .854
BN
Rickie Weeks
(Mil - 2B) No new player Notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ Col L, 5-3 69% 40/147 28 24 5 2 9 24 2 12 39 .272 .857
BN
Luis Castillo
(NYM - 2B) No new player Notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ Fla W, 7-1 4% 147/486 77 131 12 3 1 40 20 69 58 .302 .733
BN
Juan Pierre
(CWS - LF,CF) New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ Cle W, 6-0 33% 117/380 57 93 16 8 0 31 30 27 27 .308 .757
BN
Jhonny Peralta
(Cle - 3B,SS) No new player Notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ @CWS L, 6-0 23% 148/582 57 101 35 1 11 83 0 51 134 .254 .691

SP
Roy Halladay
(Phi - SP) New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ @Was W, 11-1 98% 239.0 17 10 9 0 22 35 208 2.79 1.13 7.83
SP
Josh Beckett
(Bos - SP) New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List 77% 212.1 17 6 4 0 25 55 199 3.86 1.19 8.43
SP
Jered Weaver
(LAA - SP) Player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ Min W, 6-3 93% 211.0 16 8 4 0 26 66 174 3.75 1.24 7.42
RP
Mariano Rivera
(NYY - RP) No new player Notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List 90% 66.1 3 3 0 44 7 12 72 1.76 0.90 9.77
RP
Francisco Cordero
(Cin - RP) Player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List StL L, 11-6 91% 66.2 2 6 0 39 2 30 58 2.16 1.32 7.83
P
Derek Lowe
(Atl - SP) New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List ^ ChC W, 16-5 57% 194.2 15 10 0 0 16 63 111 4.67 1.52 5.13
P
Clay Buchholz
(Bos - SP) Player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List 15% 92.0 7 4 0 0 13 36 68 4.21 1.38 6.65
P
C.J. Wilson
(Tex - RP) Player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List Tor W, 5-4 9% 73.2 5 6 0 14 3 32 84 2.81 1.33 10.26
BN
Andy Pettitte
(NYY - SP) Player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List 21% 194.2 14 8 0 0 20 76 148 4.16 1.38 6.84
BN
Dallas Braden
(Oak - SP) Player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List Sea L, 5-3 1% 136.2 8 9 0 0 9 42 81 3.89 1.36 5.33
DL
Ted Lilly
(ChC - SP) DL New player notes
Propose trade Add to Watch List @Atl L, 16-5 13% 177.0 12 9 0 0 22 36 151 3.10 1.06 7.68