Orlando Hudson or Kelly Johnson at 2nd base? WHIR!

[kemper5]

5x5 Mixed Roto
Slim pickings at 2nd base to choose from. Got Kelly Johnson right now (batting 8th for the D- Backs) Would O-Dog Hudson be a better choice?

[AtlantisBubba]

5x5 Mixed Roto
Slim pickings at 2nd base to choose from. Got Kelly Johnson right now (batting 8th for the D- Backs) Would O-Dog Hudson be a better choice?

Tough call, but I would go with Johnson. He is batting 8th which sucks, but they should move him around a bit. O-Dog will be higher up in the lineup but his offensive skills are.....well, meh. I think you get better consistency and potential out of Johnson in Arizona than you do with O-Dog in Minny

[specificist]

Honestly these guys are almost identical. Hudson will hit for a little higher AVG and Johnson has the ability to hit for a little more power. Personally, I would take O-dog, because he will probably be hitting higher in the lineup, and Kelly Johnson is coming off of a horrid year. You know what you are getting with Hudson, he's gonna hit 280, low double digit homeruns and steals, probably score 80 runs and get 160 hits. If you want to take a risk or go off of potential, take Johnson, but in that big ballpark and hitting 8th, I doubt he puts up better numbers than Hudson.

help?

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=406644