trade pedroia?

[miracles716]

i was offerd this in a 16 team league

i get back valverde, montero, scherzer, and cuddyer

i give up pedroia, zito, kendall, and beltran

any advice would help, thanks

my team

Rankings Trends Batting
Batters Opp: 4/6 O-Rank Rank % Owned H/AB R HR RBI SB AVG
Jason Kendall
(KC - C) 1015 - 2% 0/1 0 0 0 0 .000
Carlos Santana
(Cle - C) NA 1380 - 2% -/- - - - - -
Hank Blalock
(TB - 1B) NA Bal 457 - 2% -/- - - - - -
Dustin Pedroia
(Bos - 2B) NYY 26 - 98% -/- - - - - -
Mark Teahen
(CWS - 1B,3B,OF) 208 - 48% 0/3 0 0 0 0 .000
Miguel Tejada
(Bal - SS) @TB 186 - 81% -/- - - - - -
Melvin Mora
(Col - 3B) @Mil 546 - 2% -/- - - - - -
Aaron Hill
(Tor - 2B) 45 - 97% 1/4 0 0 0 0 .250
Jayson Werth
(Phi - OF) 40 - 98% 1/5 1 0 0 0 .200
Carl Crawford
(TB - OF) Bal 19 - 98% -/- - - - - -
Curtis Granderson
(NYY - OF) @Bos 55 - 98% -/- - - - - -
Juan Pierre
(CWS - OF) 278 - 50% 0/4 0 0 0 0 .000
Carlos Gomez
(Mil - OF) Col 856 - 4% 4/5 2 1 1 1 .800
Adam Lind
(Tor - OF) 59 - 97% 3/3 2 1 1 0 1.000
Ben Francisco
(Phi - OF) 340 - 2% -/- - - - - -
Kelly Johnson
(Ari - 2B) SD 868 - 4% 0/0 0 0 0 0 -
Mike Aviles
(KC - SS) 1121 - 4% -/- - - - - -
Carlos Beltran
(NYM - OF) DL 159 - 80% -/- - - - - -
Rankings Trends Pitching
Pitchers Opp: 4/6 O-Rank Rank % Owned IP W SV K ERA WHIP
Zack Greinke
(KC - P) 30 - 98% 5.0 0 0 4 0.00 0.80
Javier Vazquez
(NYY - P) @Bos 80 - 98% - - - - - -
Randy Wolf
(Mil - P) ^ Col 169 - 81% - - - - - -
Kenshin Kawakami
(Atl - P) 222 - 50% - - - - - -
Barry Zito
(SF - P) ^ @Hou 431 - 20% - - - - - -
Jason Hammel
(Col - P) @Mil 472 - 4% - - - - - -
J.J. Putz
(CWS - P) 670 - 2% 1.0 0 0 2 0.00 1.00
Aaron Cook
(Col - P) @Mil 448 - 4% - - - - - -
Jon Garland
(SD - P) @Ari 530 - 7% 0.1 0 0 0 0.00 3.00
Gil Meche
(KC - P) DL

[bazzy_51]

No way I do this deal.. Peds is way more valuable then that, and especially in a 16-teamer. Valverde/Scherzer/Cuddyer aren't mince meat, but I think Scherzer stuggles leaving the NL and going to the AL, even with the switch from a hitters park to a pitchers park. Too many questions around him to consider him an above average SP. Valverde is a closer, I never trade top value batters or pitchers even for something I can pick up much more cheaply off FA throughout the year. So your basically in my eyes down to Cuddyer for Pedroia, which isn't even close.

Yes you get some decent upgrades (Montero could be a nice sub later in the year), Valverde is the closer you don't have, Cuddyer would be nice over Gomez, but your OF is stacked as is and Scherzer could very well flop. Don't trade a sure fire bat at a thin position for a position you really don't need, a position that you can get stats from off the FA list or a couple players with potential to be good...

[skones]

No way. Pedroia is a 2nd round pick in a 16 team league. You're not getting anything back that's even close to that type of value.