Who will have the better season at short this year?

[waltb87]

Marco Scutaro, Erick Aybar, or JJ Hardy?

[Pogotheostrich]

Aybar

[BigLebowski]

Aybar

as stated

[waltb87]

OK, nevermind, I thought he was available but he is not...well how about between JJ Hardy and Marco Scutaro?

[freeling_prideful]

Tough call. I think Scutaro is the more patient hitter and probably better in some of the peripherals, but Hardy definitely has a lot more pop in his bat. Until we figure out how much of a hitters' park Target is, though, it's not clear how well Hardy's power will play. He will probably be .260/18 HR this year, and Scutaro has more of a .275/12 HR feel to me, though you should expect more run production out of Scutaro in the Red Sox lineup.

[Havok1517]

Aybar
JJ

Scutaro