Big trade. I need help.

[owenhart]

This guy in my league wants Vazquez and Markais. I was thinking of offereing this trade. Ryan Zimmerman and Ricky Nolasco for Javier Vazquez and Nick Markais. Am I giving up too much?

Here is my roster.

year 6
we start one at each postion a dh and 6 pitchers
10 team keeper league. We keep 15

my team from last year.

C: Miguel Montero
1st: Kendry Morales
2nd: Chase Utley
ss: Jimmy Rollins
3rd: Ian Stewart
of: Nick Markias
of: Grady Sizemore
of: Jason Bay
dh: Matt Kemp

bench
Shane Victorino
Yadier Molina
Scott Sizemore
Erick Aybar
Mark DeRosa
Chris Davis
Troy Glaus
Clint Barmes
Garrett Atkins,
My pitchers
p: Zack Grenike
p: Edwin Jackson
p: Andrew Bailey
p: Matt Cain
p: Javier Vazquez
p: Ubaldo Jimenez
Bench
Carlos Zambrano
Brad Penny
Huston Street
Ben Sheets
Kyle Drabek
Chris Volstad
Justin Duchscherer
Brett Myers

[Delino Deshields]

I would keep my guys since I think

Nolasco as a lot more to offer than Vazquez this year and into the future.

ZImmerman is still young too and more proven than Markakis

[CLN]

If he's willing to do the trade, I'd do it. Zimmerman is near the top at one of the most shallow positions. Sure Vazquez pitches for the Yanks, but Nolasco is a stud.

[LMack]

I'd take your side of the deal every day of the week, and twice on Sundays.

[kidsilk]

I would do that trade definitely if I were you. Zimmerman is a top3B at a weak position and Nolasco will only get better. Markakis is good but not as good as Zimm and Vazquez should put up good numbers in NY but it is worth it if you are getting Zimmerman.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=406485