Trade Mark Reynolds for Sizemore? WHIR

[qcmny181]

Should I trade Mark Reynolds for Grady Sizemore? The best FA 3B available is probably Chipper Jones so I'd be pretty shady at 3B if I made this move. I see Grady ranked higher than Reynolds on a lot of boards but I don't really understand why. Thanks for your help and as always WHIR.

-QC$

10 Team Weekly H2H Keeper League with Standard 5X5 Scoring
- We Keep 8 guys each year.

C Brian McCann
1B Ryan Howard
2B Chase Utley
SS Hanley Ramirez
3B Mark Reynolds
OF Nelson Cruz
OF Carlos Gonzalez
OF Alex Rios
UTL Billy Butler
BN Denard Span
BN Garrett Jones

SP Jon Lester
SP Cole Hamels
SP Ubaldo Jimenez
SP Chad Billingsley
SP Roy Oswalt
RP Joakim Soria
RP Andrew Bailey
BN Brian Matusz
BN Mat Latos
BN Dice-K

[healyja]

Yeah I would make the move. Chipper is a solid replacment out of waivers. It helps improve your outfield, and your infield is already stacked.

heres mine, thanks in advance

viewtopic.php?t=406511

[weiselmck]

yes, you need to make this deal. you could use the SB that sizemore offers. He will hit about .265 which is still higher than reynolds, will score more runs and steal more bases and homers and rbis i think will be close. And as was already said, Chipper is a fine replacement and will help your BA.

[abrage22]

Definetly do this. Sizemore should bounce back, and as for reynolds i think he'l go in the opposite direction.

[sadlyajetsfan]

I'd rather Sizemore by a lot. He should improve on last year and will get you well rounded stats. Good move.

viewtopic.php?t=406392