Which 3b AL only WHIR

[orejed]

AL only 9 teams 5x5 roto

c Joe Mauer
1b Kendry Morales
2b Ben Zobrist
3b Alberto Callaspo
ss Asdrubal Cabrera
of Josh Hamilton
of Alex Rios
of Juan Pierre
util Vladimir Guerrero
bench Nick Johnson
bench Sean Rodriguez

p Josh Beckett
p Scott Baker
p Jose Valverde
p Brett Anderson
p D Matsuzaka
p Jason Frasor
p Matt Guerrier
p Erik Bedard

I originally drafted Alex Gordon but dropped him for Callaspo. I also looked closely at Inge and Atkins but now Peralta is also available. Yahoo has Peralta ranked the highest of the four but I think that he's overvalued. Should I drop Callaspo and, if so, which of the other three should I add? I'd appreciate any advice. Thanks.

[BigDunn]

I like Callaspo and think that he's underrated. It also looks like he'll his 3rd in the lineup, ahead of Butler, so that could help him surprise a bunch of people. Peralta might have the higher upside though with his power potential and being a part of a better lineup. I think these two are head and shoulders above the other guys and would go with one of them, probably Peralta based on the rest of your lineup.

Help with mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=406360