Vitters/Castro Long Term Potential

[charger_ss24]

Who you like better for a long-term keeper league: Josh Vitters or Starlin Castro?

[Amatter32]

Vitters. Castro will be a decent SS but a decent 3B> decent SS. You could make a case for either player.

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd take Castro. He's more of a gamble IMO but much higher upside.

[kab21]

Castro and it's not real close imo. I think he's at least going to make it to the majors. Vitters is still an interesting prospect but he has a lot to work on. His plate discipline is borderline awful and that might get further exploited as he moves up. At the very least i think he'll move slowly as he tries to improve his plate discipline.

[Grounded Polo]

Castro, Vitters isn't a sure bet to be a MLB regular at this point.

[MaudDib]

Castro as well. Not only do I think he will be the better player but he also has a pretty open road to the majors where Vitters has ARam to beat out.