it depends on if you are really desperate for a pitcher and what your current roster looks like, but I wouldn't trade Reynolds for neither of them. if you need the pitcher, I'd actually say Verlander. Verlander is a work horse and stays in games long than Wainwright and can easily surpass him by 40-50 K's, which may speak to as why Wainwright has that lower ERA/WHIP.
12 team, H2H, 6x6
OF-Granderson, Willingham, Ad. Jones
BN-Kendrick, Furcal, Stanton
P-Hughes, Clippard, Thornton, Dempster