Pujols for Miguel Cabrera & Adam Lind WHIR

[ridetheline]

In a three year keeper league with Pujols & Cabrera going into first year and Lind going into second year. On the whole, who wins this trade?

[raek]

In a vacuum, I'd try to get another mid level player thrown in. I think its just a tad bit too much to give up.

viewtopic.php?t=406254

[thejusman1]

How many keepers are you allowed? I'm leaning towards no either way, but if it's more than a few than I'd try to get another young keeper bat thrown in, like Beckham. That might be the right price.

[ridetheline]

He has Chirs Davis, but is a HUGE fan of the Rangers, so that'd be tough. We keep 6 every year. 2 of my 6 are in their last year, and one of the others is Joe Nathan :\

Essentially what I'm considering offering is:

Albert (1st year)
Alex Rios
Porcello

for

Adam Lind (2nd year)
Jay Bruce (1st year)
Miguel Cabrera (1st year)

Is that totally ridiculous?