Would you make this deal in a keeper league?? WHIR

[Doughhead]

I am all over this. If you can get Upton and Kershaw for that package...you have to do it.

Uh, yeah. I'd be on that like Ben Roethlisberger on an average-looking girl.

[SOUTHSIDE HITMEN]

Thanks for the help with mine. I was going to say the Verlander deal, but it is a keeper and you are getting two young STUDS. Choosing between Kershaw and Hanson is your call because I see both are equal IMO. Thanks for the help.

[kingmike74]

Keeper, yes, if not, I would pass.

I am not in love with Reynolds but in an OBP league, he is good.

I am not sold on kershaw and in no means is he close to Veralnder IMO.

+ reynolds helps your overall numbers better than Upton IMO.

Good luck and thanks for taking a look at my post man.

[Seanyfever]

I'd rather have Verlander by a margin, but Upton over Reynolds has sold me.

Thanks for your post!

[BUCCOFAN]

Getting Upton in this deal is back breaker...... Kershaw might even have a finer season then Verlander this year, or Career.

DO IT,

Thanks on mine.

[craig2000000]

By now you should have taken this deal.

In a keeper I would make that deal in a second, in a redraft I would take this deal in 2 seconds. You are talking about 2 generational talents (Upton & Kershaw) for 2 regression candidates as I believe Verlander threw more pitches than any SP last year, and you are selling high on Reynolds career year.

BTW- I would still do it for Upton & Hanson, however I like Kershaw much better. Plus you get the best player in the deal, jUP

[HOOTIE]

I am all over this. If you can get Upton and Kershaw for that package...you have to do it.

[shoelessjoetara]

Do this deal. Take Kershaw.