Is This Trade Worth Making?

[rasto21585]

I have a trade offer on the table where I give morneu, smoak, avila and carrasco/daniel hudson for miguel cabrera and jose valverde. Do you think this trade is worth making?

20 team h2h dynasty league

c russel martin
1b justin morneau
2b howie kendrick
3b chase headly
ss ryan theriot
if blake dewitt
lf carlos lee
cf colby rasmus
rf justin upton
of ryan ludwick
util fucodome
bn john smoak
bn jesus montero
bn alex avila

sp jon lester
sp matt garza
sp jon danks
sp homer bailey
rp rafael soriano
rp colby lewis
rp dustin nippert
p ryan rowland smith
p doug fister
p c.j. wilson
bn charlie haegar
bn geo gonzalez
bn carlos carrasco

[MaudDib]

I don't like this for you. Morneau can be 1B stud himself, maybe not in the league of MCab but not that far off. Smoak has the potential to be a stud 1B as well, he has everything you want in a prospect - batting eye, switch hitter, patience etc. Valvarde is not a closer to trade for as he could just as easily blow up by July. Keep what you have and hope to find a closer on the WW.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=406095

[rasto21585]

bump

[rasto21585]

anyone

[miracles716]

do the deal, help me with mine
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=406325

[Seanyfever]

I don't do it for same reason above.... How far is the true gap between Morneau and M Cab??? Not enough for me. Valverde is nice, but replaceable.

HELP ME? It's a quickie.
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=406355