am i getting enough for upton?

[miracles716]

i think upton will have a huge season but i am in a 20 team league and do not have much pitching so this deal was offered to me, am i getting enough for upton?

i get back granderson, hanson and peavy

i give up upton, pineiro and gordon

my team

Miguel Montero
(Ari - C) 175 240 84% 125/425 425 61 125 30 0 16 59 1 38 78 203 .294 .478 .833 46
Mark Teixeira
(NYY - 1B) 8 18 99% 178/609 609 103 178 43 3 39 122 2 81 114 344 .292 .565 .948 85
Freddy Sánchez
(SF - 2B) 266 387 20% 134/457 457 56 134 29 3 7 41 5 22 76 190 .293 .416 .742 39
Ryan Zimmerman
(Was - 3B) 31 29 98% 178/610 610 110 178 37 3 33 106 2 72 119 320 .292 .525 .889 73
Derek Jeter
(NYY - SS) 34 15 98% 212/634 634 107 212 27 1 18 66 30 72 90 295 .334 .465 .871 46
Ryan Braun
(Mil - LF) 5 3 99% 203/635 635 113 203 39 6 32 114 20 57 121 350 .320 .551 .937 77
Rajai Davis
(Oak - CF) 184 126 71% 119/390 390 65 119 27 5 3 48 41 29 70 165 .305 .423 .783 35
Jason Heyward
(Atl - RF) NA 1347 - 77% -/- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Justin Upton
(Ari - RF) 17 44 99% 158/526 526 84 158 30 7 26 86 20 55 137 280 .300 .532 .898 63
Jeff Francoeur
(NYM - RF) 229 171 32% 166/593 593 72 166 32 4 15 76 6 23 92 251 .280 .423 .732 51
Alex Gordon
(KC - 3B) 191 947 42% 38/164 164 28 38 6 0 6 22 5 21 43 62 .232 .378 .702 12
Chase Headley
(SD - 3B,LF) 232 293 33% 142/543 543 62 142 31 2 12 64 10 62 133 213 .262 .392 .734 45
Nick Johnson
(NYY - 1B) 309 245 23% 133/457 457 71 133 24 2 8 62 2 99 84 185 .291 .405 .831 34
Rankings Trends Pitching
Pitchers Opp: 4/2 O-Rank Rank % Owned IP GS W L CG SHO SV ER HR BB K HLD ERA K/9 QS
Jeff Niemann
(TB - SP) 181 230 76% 180.2 30 13 6 2 2 0 79 17 59 125 0 3.94 6.23 13
Hiroki Kuroda
(LAD - SP) 156 187 74% 117.1 20 8 7 0 0 0 49 12 24 87 0 3.76 6.67 9
Randy Wells
(ChC - SP) 168 136 75% 165.1 27 12 10 0 0 0 56 14 46 104 0 3.05 5.66 18
Joel Piñeiro
(LAA - SP) 342 90 46% 214.0 32 15 12 3 2 0 83 11 27 105 0 3.49 4.42 21
Clay Buchholz
(Bos - SP) 288 372 41% 92.0 16 7 4 0 0 0 43 13 36 68 0 4.21 6.65 9
Carlos Mármol
(ChC - RP) 119 271 96% 74.0 0 2 4 0 0 15 28 2 65 93 27 3.41 11.31 0
Jason Frasor
(Tor - RP) 276 140 57% 57.2 0 7 3 0 0 11 16 4 16 56 4 2.50 8.74 0
Doug Davis

[HldOnMgnolia]

TMI.

I think it's fine.

[jackie hayes]

Yeah, it's a fair offer. Given the league depth and your hitting (which is stacked for such a deep league), I'd do this. (Even though it violates the 'don't give up the best player' rule for trades.)

[BigLebowski]

Yeah I think you have to do that deal. Good return when you look at your needs and dealing from your strength. I don't think you'll get much more for him.