Bruce/Nolasco for Vazquez/Dempster/Snider

[kmoneybags]

12 teams. 5x5 roto. 6 keepers with a minors system

my team

wieters (free thru 2011)
m-cab
kinsler (prado for now until kinsler comes back)
jeter
wright
j. upton
bj upton
bruce
rios
bench - gutierrez, nick johnson, swisher, alex gordon

sp
nolasco
kershaw
scherzer
danks
lilly
norris

rp
mariano
marmol
f. cordero
mike adams
joba

snider would be eligible to be kept for free thru 2011. i love bruce and like nolasco...but have the feeling that this may help my team...kinda torn. what say you?

[SpecialFNK]

i would say no. Nolasco is better than Vazquez. i think Vazquez is overrated. forget the ERA he had in 2009, thats not going to happen back in the AL with the Yankees. i wouldnt be surprised if his ERA is 4+. Nolasco was unlucky in 2009 and he will bounce back.
im also not a fan of Dempster, hes overrated too.
i like Bruce better than Snider, and im a Jays fan. Snider wont have a good AVG. he strikes out way to much. he has power potential, but so does Bruce.

[The Big Train]

Definite no for many of the same reasons mentioned by SFNK.

[Howie]

A third "no," I think that you're giving up the two best players in the deal.

[HldOnMgnolia]

No.

[MaybeThisYear]

Absolutely not. Nolasco is poised for a bounce back of a season.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=406027

[Nighttrain]

HELLLLLL NOOOO.

Bruce is best long term player in the deal
And Nolasco is best long term SP.

You get HOUSED in this deal

viewtopic.php?t=406009

[HldOnMgnolia]

Besides the first month of the season Nolasco was dominant last year - his ERA is only reflective of how unlucky he was.