Drew Stubbs or Sean Rodriguez

[mangenuis]

Who is the better upside bench/flier? I have Stubbs now for his 30 SB potential but can grab Rodriguez who has been raking all spring, just not sure if he is going to get everyday at-bats. Any thoughts? My team is solid, these guy would just be plug n play types unless they really take off.
its a 6x6 H2H league with R, RBI, SB, HR, AVG, OPS

[chadam189]

I'd go with Stubbs. Rodriguez strikes out a ton and doesn't walk very often - low BA, low R totals....not to mention he's got some PT questions compared to Stubbs, who should get 550+ PA's assuming he's healthy. Stubbs could be a Victorino-lite.

[rails80]

Yeah, I agree with Stubbs here - I drafted him as my bench bat in a 10 team league

[Members Only Jackets]

Stubbs but it's close....he's thuggin and buggin.