Trade Tulo/Nolasco for Ramirez/Lester?

[RileyRR]

So, this is my first time playing FB and my first trade request I have received. I have been asked to trade Tulo and Nolasco (my players) for Ramirez and Lester. You can see the league information and my roster below.

5x5 11-team Roto League
14 starters (C, 1B, 2B, SS, 3B, DH, 3xOF, 3xSP, 2xRP) + 4 bench
Current Team:
Montero (C), Butler + Sandoval (1B), Pedroia (2B), Tulo (SS), A-Rod (3B)
Nelson + Markakis + Victorino + Gardner + Rios + McClouth (OF)
Johnson + Nolasco + Jimenez + Anderson (SP)
Soria + Qualls (RP)

I appreciate your thoughts.

[thejusman1]

I would definitely say no. Nolasco will be around the same level as Lester this year, imo, and the difference between Tulo and Alexei is huge.

[miracles716]

what ramirez? if its hanley hell yes, aramis still yes, manny hell no, help me with mine

viewtopic.php?t=405897

[Kimbos Beard]

If its Hanley- obviously yes

If it is Armais - No
If it is Alexei - No

I think that the difference between lester and Nolasco is not big at all so I would look at it almost like Tulo for Ramirez straight up.

[thejusman1]

Lol, this is very true. I just assumed it was Alexei. You can't just say "Ramirez" in the MLB and have people know who you mean.

[Elsy]

agree with above posters

Hanley - an easy YES
Aramis - NO b/c you have AROD
Alexei - interesting but would have to say NO

[RileyRR]

Oops, my bad. It is in fact....<drum roll please>...Alexei.

So, clearly the consensus is a "NO". That was my first reaction as I also feel that Nolasco has a pretty good upside this year. But I just wanted some second opinions.

Thanks!