Keeper Trade help Please yes or no

[water boy]

ing to sI got offered this trade 14 team h2h 12keepers

I get Berkman, Hamels and Papelbon Davisd Ortiz for Jeter,Monreau and Vazquez and Austin Jackson


my roster

C A.J. Pierzynski
1B Justin Morneau
2B Clint Barmes
3B Mark Reynolds
SS Derek Jeter
OF Carlos Lee
OF Jayson Werth
OF Nyjer Morgan
Util Vladimir Guerrero
Util Josh Willingham
BN Carlos Santana
BN Austin Jackson
BN Ian Desmond
BN Orlando Caberea

Trends Pitching
IP W SV K ERA WHIP

SP Rich Harden
SP Javier Vázquez
SP Daisuke Matsuzaka DL SOON
SP Josh Beckett
RP Brian Wilson
RP Joe Nathan DL
RP Justin Masterson
P Scott Feldman
P Oliver Pérez
BN Carl Pavano
BN Franklin Morales
Frausto Carmona
DL Edinson Vólquez

[MaudDib]

I am going back and forth on this one so it must be close. I like that you are getting Hamels and you could use Papelbon. I am not a fan of Berkman but a lot of people think he will bounce back this year which means he should produce similar value to Morneau. The one problem I am having is replacing Jeter with Desmond. That is a worse then not having a closer because you can probably get a closer on the WW. I think I am going to say no but I wouldn't think it a dumb move if you accepted it.

[water boy]

I'm in the same boat also,i like then i dont.I need a top closer to replace Nathan.I do think Berkman is going to have a solid yr.The new ball in Minn concerns me a bit since its outdoors.There is still a few ss on the wire

Hardy
O Caberea and a few others

[water boy]

i'm thinking i'm going to reject this offer since Berkman went on the DL today,i dont need anymore injuries on this team.I only got 2 dl spots.once Nathan gets his and Volquez.I'll drop J Zimmereman.I already have Dice K headed to DL so i got 1 dead spot.anyone else

[water boy]

trade revised,

[water boy]

bump