Do this trade? *WHIR*

[michaelyoung4prez]

I give J Werth and Javy Vazquez and get Ichiro and Beckett. I want to unload Vaz but I feel like Werth is due for a monster year while Ichiro is on the downside...

10 Team Head to Head League
C-McCann
1B-Morneau
2B-Kinsler
3B-Figgins
SS-S. Drew
IF-A. Hill
LF-Braun
CF-Werth
RF-Ethier
OF-Dexter
Util-Asdrubal
BN-Aybar
SP-Greinke
SP-J. Vazquez
RP-Franky Fran
RP-Valverde
P-Wandy
P-Peavy
P-Shields
BN-Harden
BN-Slowey
BN-Matusz

[da bears]

I wouldn't take that trade, marginal upgrade if you ask me. Even if Javy has an era around 4 he's still going to get you 15+ W's/200+ K's which is very valuable. I agree with what you are thinking on the other two guys involved but think you can probably land a better SP in return for that package.


viewtopic.php?f=26&t=405753&p=3232658#p3232658

[miracles716]

i would do it u get the better player in both positions, beckett is a top 10 pitcher and vazy has a tendency to do horribly after a breakout season, kinda like al leiter did, plus ichiro i good for 200 hits .330 + average, 30-40 steals and now that he hits 3rd, close to 100 rbis take the deal and run

[michaelyoung4prez]

What about countering with...

Morneau and Vaz for Morales and Beckett?

[da bears]

What about countering with...

Morneau and Vaz for Morales and Beckett?

I love that one if he would bite on it. thanks for the help on mine.

[SpecialFNK]

i like the 2nd one. im not a fan of Vazquez. i think you can forget his ERA being anywhere close to what it was in Atlanta. im thinking 4+ back in the AL in Yankee Stadium.
i would also rather have Morales over Morneau. i havnt checked recently, but while doing pre rankings before spring training there was concern over Morneau's back. that raised a red flag to me and i had no interest in him.
Beckett is going to be better than Vazquez and i think Morales is atleast even if not better than Morneau even if healthy.


help?
viewtopic.php?t=405759