C Geovany Soto 1B Albert Pujols* 2B Chase Utley* 3B Alex Rodriguez* SS Jason Bartlett OF Jason Bay OF Grady Sizemore OF Carlos Gonzalez UT Rajai Davis UT Magglio Ordonez UT James Loney BN Dexter Fowler BN Alcides Escobar
SP Roy Halladay* SP Zach Greinke* SP CC Sabathia* SP Jorge De La Rosa SP Ted Lilly SP Mark Buehrle SP Derek Lowe
No way. Don't do it. Granderson is not worth it (and this is coming from a Yankee fan). You have a shot to win this year. Don't play for your keepers next year when you have a legit shot. I think making this trade hurts your chances of winning now. You don't need the upgrade to Broxton, cause your pen is fine as is and losing Utley would do irreparable damage to your lineup.
sigriffey, you need to stop thinking of ways to jettison your season, haha. Pujols-Utely-Arod and Halladay-Greinke-CC basically guarantee you a championship this year, and you drafted pretty damn good supporting players who are very viable keepers themselves (Bay, Grady Sizemore, CarGo). And I'm sure if your 6 keeper contracts are expiring, a few other owners will have a similar problem, allowing you to draft good talent next year as well. No need to freak out!!