gonzalez/victorino/uggla for phillips/abreu/eithier...WHIR

[casem2k2]

I Trade: Adrian Gonzalez, Shane Victorino, Dan Uggla

I get: Brandon Phillips, Bobby Abreu, Andre Eithier

Does this trade help or hurt me?

Im in a 10 team roto league....runs, hr, rbi, sb, obp

My Roster
C R.Martin
C K.Shoppach
1B A.Gonzalez
2B I.Kinsler
3B A.Rodriguez
SS J.Bartlett
CI C.Davis
MI D.Uggla
OF G.Sizemore
OF N.Cruz
OF S.Victorino
OF J.Kubel
Util R.Davis
Util J.Cantu
b C.Rasmus
b T.Helton
b J.Peralta
b H.Matsui
b R.Hernandez

SP C.Lee
SP Josh Johnson
SP J.Peavy
SP J.Jurrjens
RP B.Wilson
RP T.Hoffman
P M.Gonzalez
P M.Lindstrom
P A.Burnett
b R.Dempster
b J.Happ

[casem2k2]

any help?

[philaphan]

I wouldn't do it. Gonzalez is the best player in the trade and losing him hurts you more than phillips/abreu/eithier would help. I would stand pat with what you have.

Please help me
viewtopic.php?t=405320

[fierro33]

it hurts your starting lineup...if you do it u have to play helton at 1b....not good.....but its basically gonzo/uggla for phillips/ethier because abreu and victorino are a wash. Its a tossup...who is his 1b?