PLEASE HELP!!!!!!!!!!

[zazzal87]

would this be a good trade for me??

getting
felix hernadez
david wright

giving up
ryan zimmerman
justin upton
josh johnson

My Roster
C Miguel Montero
1B Prince Fielder
2B Brandon Phillips
3B Ryan Zimmerman
SS Hanley Ramirez
OF Justin Upton
OF Matt Kemp
OF Andrew McCutchen
OF Julio Borbon
U Gordon Beckham
BN Marco Scutaro
BN Juan Pierre
BN Nick Johnson
BN Colby Rasmus
SP Clayton Kershaw
SP Josh Johnson
RP Billy Wagner
RP Frank Franciso
P CJ Wilson
P Jason Frasor
P Chad Billingsley
P Kevin Slowey
BN Scott Kazmir
BN David Price
BN Phil Hughes
BN Matt Guerrier

[Hustler8800]

Don't do this deal.
Zimmerman is extremely close to Wright in value. While Wright is worth more, it is not by much.
Felix is worth more than Josh Johnson, but Johnson is still a top option at SP. Justin Upton is waaaaayyy too valuable to justify an upgrade at SP, and a slight upgrade at 3B.

[philaphan]

Agree with the rest....you are giving up too much. I think the other side wins of this deal. Zim is close to Wright. Upton is a star! Stand pat.

Please help
viewtopic.php?t=405320