I GET BAY/BUEHRLE I GIVE UP BELTRAN/PEAVY

[PaulBertini]

Should i give up beltran and peavy to get bay and buehrle?

14 Team non keeper. (Runs, HR, RBI, BB, TB, AVG, Steals)


C - Iannetta
1 - A. Gonzalez
2 - Utley
3 - I. Stewart
S - Jeter
OF - Dunn
OF - R. Davis
OF - Quentin
UT - N. Johnson

Bench C. Ross
DL - Beltran

(Wins, HR, K, ERA, WHIP, Quality Starts, Saves)

SP - Beckett
SP - Cain
SP - Peavy
RP - Bronxton
RP - Valverde
RP - Aardsma
RP - Dotel

Bench - Lilly, P. Hughes, Lirano, K. Wood

[zepfan]

I like this one for you. I think the upgrade from Beltran to Bay makes up for the difference between Peavy and Buerle. I also think the players you're receiving are less of a health risk which is a nice plus.

[JetsFan13]

I agree with the prior post I think the players you are getting back are less of a health risk. I also think Peavy slips just a little with a full year in the AL and Bay will play for atleast a month probably 2 before Beltran gets back.


a little help back is appreciated.
viewtopic.php?t=405183

[bazzy_51]

I like this one for you. I think the upgrade from Beltran to Bay makes up for the difference between Peavy and Buerle. I also think the players you're receiving are less of a health risk which is a nice plus.

+1

Id rather have the value of Bay's bat actually contributing to my roster and lose a W or 2 and a few Ks then have Peavy and Beltran and have Carlos ride my DL all year... Or big chunks of the year...