Slowey or Carmona over Matusz?

[dubstar]

Slowey and Carmona are having great springs, for whatever that's worth. Carmona still scares me a bit. I like Matusz, but I wonder if Slowey or Carmona is a better option for me. Doesn't help that Matusz pitches in the AL East. Thoughts? Slowey would give me 3 Twins starters, not sure if that is good or bad. Guess it depends on how Target Field plays.

10 team h2h keeper: avg., hr, rbi, r, sb, xbh
era, w, sv, k, whip, qs

C Pierzynski
1B Fielder
2B Pedroia
3B Sandoval
SS Drew
OF Kemp, Sizemore, Cruz
UTIL D Lee
BN Quentin, Bourn

SP Greinke, Kershaw, W Rodriguez, Baker, Romero, Liriano, Matusz
RP Soria, Cordero, Franklin

[Pythagoras]

Slowey is the best out of that bunch right now, but Matusz has a way higher ceiling especially in a keeper league. He'll only get better. I'd stay away from Carmona. I really think Baltimore should be quite a bit better this year. Personally, I'd roll the dice and go Matusz and his upside. Good luck!


viewtopic.php?f=26&t=405114

[Fenris-77]

I like Slowey a lot for this year, and Matusz does have a whole mess of upside. That said, I'm not sure I drop Matusz for Slowey. I'd be tempted tp try and swing a 2-1 trade to open up a slot for Slowey though.

[tribefan08]

slowey is the best pitcher by far.

[Willie_McGee]

Slowey is fully recovered from that wrist injury and, as you mentioned, has been lights out this spring, which is a good sign coming off that injury.

Slowey is the best of those 3, IMO, and Matusz follows. If you plan/are able to keep Matusz, that makes him even more appealing.

[dubstar]

Slowey is fully recovered from that wrist injury and, as you mentioned, has been lights out this spring, which is a good sign coming off that injury.

Slowey is the best of those 3, IMO, and Matusz follows. If you plan/are able to keep Matusz, that makes him even more appealing.

We only keep 4, so Matusz would not be kept.

[Seanyfever]

Slowey- yes.

Carmona- no way

LEND THIS CAFE BROTHER YOUR VOICE
viewtopic.php?t=405249

[HOOTIE]

I like Matusz myself

[dubstar]

thanks for all the feedback, I am leaning towards just holding onto Matusz.

Man, Carmona pitched great again Saturday! I am gonna kick myself if this guy is for real again and I pass him up, haha.