Trade: Reynolds and 16th for Zimmerman (WHIR)

[Hummus]

As my earlier post illuminated, I am in a 12-team, 6-keeper 11x11 roto. I have Reynolds, but I am not sold on him and really like Zimmerman this year. He has offered me Zimmerman for my 16th and Reynolds or straight up for the first overall non-keeper pick (Johan, Kendry, and V-Mart are the best available).

Do I do either of these?

Keepers:
Haren
Kemp
Sizemore
Holliday
Morneau
Reynolds

Leave a link - Thanks

[dave knight]

I would trade Reynolds.

If you start two catchers, take the pick and V-Mart.

If you only have one catcher then take the best producer in Kendry, who is more likely to repeat his numbers than Zimmerman or especially Reynolds.

[Kimbos Beard]

I would make the Zimmerman plus the 16th round pick move. I assume that it is actually the 16th round and not the 10th round (where you count the 6 keepers as the first six rounds). Either way I am still making the move.

I love Zimmerman's current production an upside way more than Reynold's. And I really don't value the draft pick that much at all. By the time the 16th round rolls around in a 12 team league with 6 keepers, you would probably be reaching an hoping for players anyway.

[hopsjr2]

I would take the trade and go with the #1 overall non-keeper pick and snag VMART. If it's a one catcher league, you can consider Morales, but you are already pretty set with Morneau

Some help?
viewtopic.php?t=404956