***EDITED A. Soriano /Peavy plus for VMART plus...whir!!!

[Elsy]

Just want to get some opinions. 14 team 17 man keeper(28 man roster) with deep farm teams (15 players - grows by 3 each year). I think Peavy will return to form this year and would like to add him to my staff, is this a good deal for me?

Get - Jake Peavy/Alfonso Soriano/Ryan Doumit
Give - Victor Martinez/Garrett Jones/Ross Detwiler

Roster:
C - Victor Martinez
1B - Adrian Gonzalez
2B - Aaron Hill
3B - Alex Rodriguez
SS - Hanley Ramirez
OF - Adam Lind, Carlos Lee, Garrett Jones
Util - Raul Ibanez/Jeff Francoeur
BN - Jose Bautista/Casey McGehee/Daniel Murphy/Kosuke Fukudome

SP - Roy Halladay/ Tim Hudson/Ricky Romero/Shaun Marcum/Jeff Francis
RP - David Aardsma/Joe Nathan(out for year)/Kerry Wood(out until mid-May???)/Jason Frasor/ Ryan Madson

Farm team:
Kyle Drabek SP, Jesus Montero C, Brett Wallace 1B/3B, Chad Huffman OF, Davis Romero P, Phillipe Aumont SP, Brad Mills SP, Kevin Ahrens 3B, Ross Detwiler SP, J.P. Arencibia C, Jeff Larish 3B, Ryan Adams 2B, Zachary Wheeler SP, Matthew Davidson 3B, Kentrail Davis OF

[Jacksonvillezo]

I like the deal if you take the Bay-Lee out of it. I am not a fan of Bay in Citifield this year. I think Lee is a better OF in 2010 and beyond.

[Elsy]

I like the deal if you take the Bay-Lee out of it. I am not a fan of Bay in Citifield this year. I think Lee is a better OF in 2010 and beyond.

My only issue with that is, even though I'm not sure about Bay at Citi this year either, without him am I getting the right value for VMART?

[COOPERSTOWN]

VMART will play everyday because boston uses him as DH and 1st on his days off - One of two elite catchers that plays everyday. Positional drop off too huge to give up on Vmart - Especially for pitching. Too erratic.


KEEP VMERT

thanks for the help on my question.

[dave knight]

Any time you're giving up the two best players in a deal, it's an immediate 'no' from me.

[Elsy]

What if I made it Garrett Jones instead of Carlos Lee? Would that make it a better value for me?

[dave knight]

What if I made it Garrett Jones instead of Carlos Lee? Would that make it a better value for me?

That's not bad. I'd consider it given your roster, but I'd see if you could get a different pitcher since I'm not a big Peavy in the Cell fan.

[michaelyoung4prez]

V-Mart >>> Peavy. Yes you are thin after Doc at SP but V-Mart is top 3 catcher and Peavy isn't top 25 SP. Plus Soriano is horrible now

Big No