A.GOnzalez/Uggla for Phillips/Eithier...WHIR

[casem2k2]

Should I trade Adrian GOnzalez/Dan Uggla for Brandon Phillips/Andre Either???

Im in a 10 team roto league....runs, hr, rbi, sb, obp

My Roster
C R.Martin
C K.Shoppach
1B A.Gonzalez
2B I.Kinsler
3B A.Rodriguez
SS J.Bartlett
CI C.Davis
MI D.Uggla
OF G.Sizemore
OF N.Cruz
OF S.Victorino
OF J.Kubel
Util B.Hawpe
Util J.Cantu
b C.Rasmus
b T.Helton
b J.Peralta
b H.Matsui
b R.Hernandez

SP C.Lee
SP Josh Johnson
SP J.Peavy
SP J.Jurrjens
RP B.Wilson
RP T.Hoffman
P M.Gonzalez
P M.Lindstrom
P A.Burnett
b R.Dempster
b M.Buehrle

[Elsy]

Easily....NO! You are definately not getting enough in return. Yes there is a upgrade from Uggla to Phillips but not as much of one as the downgrade from AGON to Eithier. If you got a solid 1B added in then maybe consider it then, but even then may not do it. If you already have another backup 1B get a better OF in return.

[casem2k2]

any morehelp?

[KronJon]

NO.

OBP being counted is the deal breaker. Phillips puts up a horrible OBP. Gonzalez put up .400 and Uggla around .350. It's just not an even deal when you consider this.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=404933

[GOGOGADGETFLOW]

NO you already have kinsler lol.

[sha]

i agree with the 1st two replies. AGonz is too much to part with. i am not a huge phillips fan and i think gonzalez is massively underrated. i'd stay put.

viewtopic.php?t=404925

[michaelyoung4prez]

No, Uggla as your MI is sufficient enough since you are great at 2B. Don't trade A-Gon for something you don't really need

HELP viewtopic.php?f=26&t=404931

[dave knight]

That's actually relatively fair, but I'd stick with the best player in Gonzalez because of power potential especially if traded.