Which of these Offers Should I Accept and Why?

[rasto21585]

There are 3 trades I am considering. Which of the following should I accept and why?

#1 I give jesus montero, ubaldo and gio gonzalez for david wright
#2 I give ubaldo and alex avila for mccutchen and heyward
#3 I give ubaldo and sandoval for longoria and heyward


20 Team Yahoo H2H Dynasty League

c russel martin
1b justin morneau
2b howie kendrick
3b pablo sandoval
ss ryan theriot
if chase headley
lf carlos lee
cf colby rasmus
rf ryan ludwick
of fuodome
util aki iwamura
bn jesus montero
bn xavier nady
bn dayan viciedo
bn alex avila

sp jon lester
sp wandy rodriguez
sp jon danks
sp ubaldo jimenez
rp george sherrill
rp rafael soriano
rp colby lewis
rp dustin nippert
p ryan rowland smith
p jeremie guthrie
phiroki kuroda
bn geo gonzalez
bn carlos carrasco

[Epiphany]

I like trade offer #3. Longoria is better than Sandoval. He will outperform him in three categories: HR, R, RBI. Your OF is kinda of weak IMO, and Heyward looks like a safe bet/can't miss talent that will greatly improve your OF for years to come. You have good pitching depth and pitchers are less consistent year in and year out - so I can part w/ Ubaldo for a future stud in Heyward.

[sreill]

I like #1 alot

[rasto21585]

I like to do trade #1 but i feel that would leave my pitching thin and lose my prize prospect. Damn this is a tough decision.

[rasto21585]

bump

[rails80]

Honestly - #3 and it's not really even a question in my mind.

[rasto21585]

bump please

[HldOnMgnolia]

I like #1 and #3.

[rasto21585]

Maybe I should do both #1 and #3. The problem with this I would have to trade both ubaldo and lester. Yikes!!!

[rails80]

You can't do both unless you trade the same player 2x. I don't even know why the debate. Getting Longoria for Ubaldo and Sandoval is a steal - add in Heyward and it's a slam-dunk.