B Molina for J Votto or B Butler?

[captkirkcud]

A guy in my league is looking to move 1 of his 1st baseman Joey Votto or Billy Butler for a catcher, I currently own Benji Molina. I have Mark reynolds at 1st but i could move him to 3rd in place of Ian Stewart. Should i make this trade, i would have to drop one of my bench players Theriot or Ordonez to pick up another catcher? The only catchers in FA right now are M Olivo or maybe I-Rod, Salty. I can always worry about another catcher down the road don't you think

[jackie hayes]

Wait, you were offered this trade? Holy hell, yes. Votto for Molina is highway robbery.

[captkirkcud]

I agree, i think this is a no brainer, who cares about catcher right?

[jackie hayes]

Well, if it were Mauer/VMart/McCann, maybe not, but Molina? Votto is a 3rd round pick, a 1b with good power, good avg, hitting in one of the best hr parks in the majors. Easy, easy call.

I'd do the trade for Butler, too, but Votto? I'd be tripping over myself to click the accept button.

[Kimbos Beard]

Do the trade....but expect the angry vetos

[soty]

If you are being offered Votto for Molina take it and run.

[thejusman1]

Butler is a steal, Votto is felony robbery. I'd be all over this trade, and yes, you can worry about a catcher later.

[itzyaboyrd]

Thats a down right still for Votto. I'd do the deal quickly

[Johnny Tuttle]

Merry Christmas. You've obviously been a good little boy.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=404885

[PavanoAllstars]

????????????????????????????

VOTTO

help me too: posting.php?mode=post&f=26