Does this help me? whir

[Elsy]

Just want to get some opinions on this offer, just not sure. 14 team 17 man keeper with deep farm teams (15 players - grows by 3 each year). The other owner has been after Montero since the off season.

Get - Billy Butler/Nyjer Morgan/Ryan Perry (has to be called up)
Give - Adrian Gonzalez/Jesus Montero

Roster:
C - Victor Martinez
1B - Adrian Gonzalez
2B - Aaron Hill
3B - Alex Rodriguez
SS - Hanley Ramirez
OF - Adam Lind, Carlos Lee, Garrett Jones
Util - Raul Ibanez/Jeff Francoeur
BN - Jose Bautista/Casey McGehee/Daniel Murphy/Kosuke Fukudome

SP - Roy Halladay/ Tim Hudson/Ricky Romero/Shaun Marcum/Jeff Francis
RP - David Aardsma/Joe Nathan(out for year)/Kerry Wood(out until mid-May???)/Jason Frasor/ Ryan Madson

Farm team:
Kyle Drabek SP, Jesus Montero C, Brett Wallace 1B/3B, Chad Huffman OF, Davis Romero P, Phillipe Aumont SP, Brad Mills SP, Kevin Ahrens 3B, Ross Detwiler SP, J.P. Arencibia C, Jeff Larish 3B, Ryan Adams 2B, Zachary Wheeler SP, Matthew Davidson 3B, Kentrail Davis OF

Also still have 3 draft picks (offline draft) to select or 2 if I do the deal and have to bring Perry up from farm team.

[Elsy]

bump...anyone?

[APAP]

Honestly, I think this deal is completely terrible for you.

[footballisbetter.com]

Honestly, I think this deal is completely terrible for you.

I really don't like it at all either

[jasonpm311]

Thanks for the help on my Haren question. As for this one, I'd ABSOLUTELY stand pat. No way would I give up Gonzalez without getting proven value in return. I don't think Butler is enough. Don't do it.

[Elsy]

Thanks guys. The original talks were him mini-shopping Lincecum so I offered a deal and he countered wanting way too much. I countered back with something similar and he rejected and came back with this. Thanks again for all the input.