5th keeper.. Kershaw or C. Davis?

[dracovonborax]

it looks like i'll be going with ARod, Greinke, King Felix, Lind, and Ubaldo Jimenez coming over in a trade. would you go with the potential bat of Davis since you already have the 3 sp or you think Kershaw will have the season the sleeper list here says he will?

[Geek]

Chris Davis? Kershaw has WAY more value. You could get a much better bat by trading Kershaw--someone like Torii Hunter or Ibanez.

Please help with mine:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=404671

[HOOTIE]

Kershaw by alot

[ltrocq]

Kershaw since he's actually shown some of his potential in the majors

[Guzman24]

Kershaw for sure. not even close.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=404678

[Kimbos Beard]

I would say Kershaw has way more value than Davis. However I am guessing since you are keeping 4 pitchers that your offense is going to look like butt this year.

You will probably end up having to look for hitting in trades. That being said the right move is still to keep Kershaw over davis.

[Brizee8]

Definitely keep Kershaw. It'll be a lot of pitchers, but Kershaw has much more value. Davis is still very much an enigma, and Kershaw has a much better chance of being a top contributor. In this case, keep the best player and worry about having too much pitching later. You can always trade the extra pitching for hitting.

viewtopic.php?t=404553