Would you make this trade?

[xirix]

League: Yahoo HTH 14 team
Cats: R, 1B, 2B, 3B, HR, RBI, SB, K, AVG, OPS

Give: Rollins and Ethier
Get: Brandon Phillips, Elvis Andrus, Corey Hart

Already have
Russell Martin (c)
Kendry Morales (1b)
Ian Kinsler (2b)
Aramis Ramirez (3b)
Shane Victorino (of)
Brad Hawpe (of)
Juan Rivera (of)
Alex Rios (reserve of)
Todd Helton (reserve 1b)
Nick Johnson (reserve 1b)

Basically Elvis for Rollins, Ethier for Brandon, and Hart thrown in. Plus a drop of one of those reserves.

First thing I see is power drop off, but I'm concerned about Kinsler's injury and Rollins' age. I'm not convinced Rollins is going to ever put up another solid season, although he's having a great spring. Getting Brandon for Ethier seems like a steal to me.

[Element]

You already have Kinsler at 2B. So where does Phillips play exactly? This doesn't make sense for you.

[Seanyfever]

Kinsler at 2B made me look again as well. You may have your own motive, but I think not.

Help out a Cafe Brother?
viewtopic.php?t=404587