Trade help Arod for Hanley and others WHIR!!!

[sreill]

I trade
AROD
Verlander
Reyes

I get:
Hanley
Wright
Scherzer


My staff without verlander will look like this:

Hamels
Zambrano
Baker
Hudson
Scherzer

[PinStripe Pride 718]

u need verlander but hanley amazing but arod is arod i say stay with what u have


help me please
viewtopic.php?t=404514

[sreill]

bump

[AmazinMeTS86]

I would stick with what you have..

A-Rod > Wright

Verlander > Scherzer

Reyes < Hanley

Your gain would be the addition of Hanley, but you'd be giving away too much IMO

[footballisbetter.com]

ARod > Wright
Reyes < Hanley
Verlander > Scherzer

Losing Verlander would hurt your staff. I say no deal.

[slcdcricket]

I say definitely not. Depending on the health of Reyes you will probably get more out of AROD and Reyes as compared to that of Hanley and Wright. But it'll be close. The kicker is you're losing a MUCH better pitcher than he is. I say NO

Mine?
viewtopic.php?t=404537

[rails80]

Verlander is the tipping point here. I'd probably rather have Hanley/Wright over Reyes/ARod but the pitching difference is just too much to overcome.

[sreill]

Am I the only one that doesnt thin reyes is worth that much? His only asset is steals and he is coming off a hamstring surgery.

BTW this is a H2H not roto..

[sreill]

Anymore opinions? Im leaning towards pulling the trigger on this

[sreill]

.