Chone Figgins for Josh Hamilton

[Padres Fan]

i was offered Josh Hamilton for my Chone Figgins, but I am looking to counter for either Hunter Pence, Jay Bruce or Carlos Quentin, which of the 4 would you do for Figgins.

as you can see my OF depth is weak, auction style draft and I left the OF till last due to depth but got out bidded.

My Team
C-Joe Mauer
1B-Justin Morneau
2B-Dan Uggla
3B-Ryan Zimmerman
SS-JJ Hardy
MI-Everth Cabrera
CI-Chone Figgins
OF-Cody Ross
OF-Jayson Werth
OF-Corey Hart
OF-Dexter Fowler
OF-Colby Rasmus
UTIL-Lance Berkman
BN-Miguel Tejada
BN-Austin Jackson
BN-Ryan Theriot

P-Zack Greinke
P-Johan Santana
P-Jered Weaver
P-Adam Wainwright
P-Mark Beuhrle
P-Mariano Rivera
P-Trevor Hoffman
P-Jon Rauch
BN-Aroldis Chapman

His Team:
C-Miguel Montero
1B-Adam Dunn
2B-Dustin Pedroia
3B-Alex Rodriguez
SS-Yunel Escobar
MI-Ian Kinsler
CI-Billy Butler
OF-Josh Hamilton
OF-Carl Crawford
OF-Jay Bruce
OF-Hunter Pence
OF-Carlos Quentin
UTIL-Shin-Soo Choo

P-Javier Vasquez
P-Jake Peavey
P-Tim Hudson
P-Jair Jurrjens
P-Heath Bell
P-Brian Wilson
P-Carlos Marmol
P-Ryan Madson
BN-Wandy Rodriguez
BN-Ted Lilly
BN-Edwin Jackson
BN-Neftali Feliz

[oldmanbean]

Hamilton is hitting well this spring, but has to stay healthy. My opinion would be Pence or Bruce, leaning towards Pence.

thanks for help on mine!

[Cypher74]

I actually like all four of those guys...I think Quentin will have a big bounceback year, and its only a matter of time for Bruce. Still, Pence is the safe pick.

Help if you can?

viewtopic.php?t=404450

[raiders_umpire]

I would take Hamilton easily over Figgins. I would also take Quentin or Bruce over Figgins, but if the offer is Hamilton, I would jump all over it.

[Padres Fan]

should i try for Pence first then settle for Hamilton?

[sigriffey]

I'd try to upgrade Hardy too, depending on how much you like him.

Maybe Escobar and Pence for Hardy and Figgins

I may be in the minority on Hardy though...

[raiders_umpire]

should i try for Pence first then settle for Hamilton?

No Hamilton is easily the better player, just accept that deal.

[thejusman1]

You have to do that. HAMMY baby.

[xtreme99]

Its a great deal but there is no chance Hamilton makes 120 games this year. Dude is made of glass so don't be upset when he lands on the DL a few times this year.

[HOOTIE]

I would take Hamilton easily over Figgins. I would also take Quentin or Bruce over Figgins, but if the offer is Hamilton, I would jump all over it.