Trade J Upton for Peavy or Wandy? WHIR

[aillon]

I have the worst SP staff in history and to many OFs. I have my choice of trading my Justin Upton for his Peavy or Wandy Rodriguez? Who should I pick?

[NickC19]

Thats an awful trade for you. J Upton is worth alot more than Peavy or Wandy. I know that wasnt your question but just sayin.

[ChicksDigTheLongBall]

Who are your other OFs? You can gate much more for Upton. Maybe even a Top 5 pitcher. Peavy and Wandy together for Upton would make much more sense than just one of them.

[footballisbetter.com]

I agree that you should get much more for Upton then either Peavy or Wandy. Can you look to trade one of your other OF's instead? Pass on that deal.

[Cypher74]

Im with these guys - Upton is worth more than that so I wouldn't do that deal. But of the two I'd take Wandy.

Help if you can?

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=404450&p=3224370#p3224370

[zippytrash]

I wouldn't think of dealing JUpton for either Peavy or Wandy right now... Maybe for both of them, but even then. Post your team, and we can help you out more.

Look at mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=404230

[Padres Fan]

agreed we need to see your team, but I would be hesitant for even both of them, you could get better.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=404447

[raiders_umpire]

Trade Upton for Felix or Greinke not Peavy or Wandy.

[Padres Fan]

Trade Upton for Felix or Greinke not Peavy or Wandy.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=404447

[aillon]

Here is my team, the problem is that is a ESPN 6 SP a week, SP are way more valuable.

C Miguel Montero, Ari C [Recent News]

1B Pablo Sandoval, SF 3B, 1B [Breaking News]

2B Brandon Phillips, Cin 2B

3B David Wright, NYM 3B

SS Elvis Andrus, Tex SS

OF Ryan Braun, Mil OF

OF Matt Kemp, LAD OF

OF Carl Crawford, TB OF

UTIL Justin Upton, Ari OF [Recent News]

Bench Ichiro Suzuki, Sea OF

Bench Curtis Granderson, NYY OF [Recent News]

@Bos

P
SP Matt Garza, TB SP
+0
SP Tim Hudson, Atl SP
+0
SP Rich Harden, Tex SP [Breaking News]
+0
SP Wade Davis, TB SP [Recent News]

SP Mat Latos, SD SP [Recent News]

SP Jonathan Sanchez, SF SP

RP Francisco Rodriguez, NYM RP

RP Andrew Bailey, Oak RP DTD [Breaking News]

Bench Joba Chamberlain, NYY SP [Breaking News]