Its hard to say due to the fact that Holliday has Pujols to support him in the line up...but based on position scarcity i'd go with Kinsler. Can't go wrong either way
Rosario Trumbo Kinsler D. Gordon Frazier Kemp J.Upton Moss Rizzo Hosmer Alvarez A.Jackson, Carpenter H.Ramirez, Eaton Puig
I'd go with Kinsler by a slight edge, although in a 10-teamer, you could see Pedroia, Cano, or Phillips in the next round, each of whom I wouldn't mind in the least bit to fall back on.
If Wright or Lincecum is there though, I'd take either one over Kinsler or Holliday instead.
In a 10 teamer, I would go with Holliday and expect to land one of Cano or Phillips in Round 3. Like AD though, if Wright is available, I would go with him over either Holliday or Kinsler.