I think Mccutchen is in for a really solid year, therefore I would choose him. But I agree with the all the other picks in the sense that you could find a better second basemen than hill, or drop him completely and keep Quentin.
I do like Mccutchen, but there is tons of speed in the outfield this year that can be found later. There aren't many 35-40 home run studs though and although Hamilton and Quentin are injury prone they are definitely capable of doing so.
I'm a hill believer. Numbers will regress but only because he might not get 680 at bats again. Thanks for the replies. Hamilton has been mashing during spring, and is a former 1st overall so if healthy could be a first rounder, Quentin gives you 35 + Bombs with 100 rbi's and a decent average and mccutchen has upside but has one year under his belt. The biggest factor with Hamilton being discounted is his 16th round cost compared to Quentin's 25th and Mccutchen's 25th, but I for sure want Hill's 25th round when he is going 4th-7th round for a 2nd basemen.