Arod, McCann Big Trade... WHIR!

[raek]

6x6 (ops) H2H 16-team dynasty (no salaries) 1st Year

I give: McCann, C Jones, Harden

I get: ARod, Soto, Liriano

We are currently just haggling on the pitchers. He offered this, and I countered with Kuroda instead of Hardin, and he declined. Should I just accept this to get the deal done? I went hitter heavy in the draft, and wasnt thinking long term. I'd really like to move Chipper since hes unreliable and getting up there in age.

My Team:
C: McCann
1B: Cabrera
2B: Hudson
SS: Rollins
3B: C Jones
MI: Young, Jr
CI: Berkman
OF: Lee
OF: Hunter
OF: Gonzalez
OF: Morgan
OF: Rivera
Util: Rolen
BN: Uribe, Cameron, Gwynn

SP: W Rodriguez
SP: Hardin
SP: Kuroda
SP: Harang
SP: Niemann
RP: Soriano
RP: Lindstrom
BN: Wolf
BN: Tillman

His Team:
C: Soto
1B: Reynolds
2B: Cano
3B: ARod
SS: Hardy
MI: Peralta
CI: Glaus
OF: McClouth
OF: Soriano
OF: Hawpe
OF: Ludwick
OF: Stubbs
Util: Branyon
BN: Smoak

SP: Carpenter
SP: Nolasco
SP: Liriano
SP: Zambrano
SP: Matusz
RP: Rivera
RP: Marmol
BN: Santana, Sherril, Saito, Nathan

[saemick]

I would definitely make this trade. I think Soto will have a bounce-back year, and both Liriano & Harder could have comparable stats, while the added value in getting ARod over Chipper is HUGE!!! Do this 100%

help:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=404102

[Ravens Black]

DEFINETLY!!! Sorry but you would be crazy not to. Soto lost weight and will bounce back and Liriano has been solid all spring the A-Rod is just crazy for the guy to give up for the package he wants.

DO IT

[mfisher17]

I agree with the other people who responded. What you lose at Catcher will be more than made up by the boost at 3B and SP. I'd definitely take this deal!

[silverlionlb]

Pull the trigger, ARod is great value at that price

[910BronxBomber]

Absolutely take this trade. All three of the guys you listed are due for bounce-back type years. Especially lirano, I think he could really turn some heads this season. Mccan is a solid catcher, but Soto is a nice replacement and Chipper has liability written all over him. Pull the trigger, pop some champaign, and celebrate a great trade to start the season .

viewtopic.php?t=404114

-910BB

[footballisbetter.com]

No brainer for me. Do it. I wouldn't even haggle over the pitchers.