Please rank these RP (WHIR)

[BUCCOFAN]

I need to compliment my pair of closers (K-Rod and Qualls)

Who out of these options would you go with?

RP - M.Capps (WAS) (struggled badly last year, and so far this spring)
RP - M.Gonzalez (BAL) (always an injury concern)
RP - K.Wood (CLE) (seems to be gone for 6-8 weeks)
RP - C.Perez (CLE) (takes over for Wood, does he keep the gig?)
RP - Lindstrom (HOU) or Lyon (HOU)
RP - S.Gervacio (HOU) (sleeper to take over the gig by midseason?)
RP - R.Madson (PHI) (looks to begin the season as the phillies closer, Lidge injured?)
RP - M.Thornton (CHI-W) (two quality seasons, primed and ready to take over for Jenks)
RP - J.Frasor or K.Gregg or S.Downs (a situation to stay away from?)

Please leave a link will help in return,

Thanks

[diamondllama]

1. Madson




2. Lindstrom
3. Thornton
4. Perez

I have no real preference on the rest. Also, those ranking depend on how bad you need the SVs. I'd value Thornton above Lindstrom if you aren't desperate. He's a better pitcher, imo, but I'm not sure he can close. Still, I'd put Madson way at the top of this one.

[reblaze369]

madson
gonzalez
lindstrom
perez

every1 else


help w mine?

viewtopic.php?t=404036

[Da Man]

Capps closely followed by Gonzalez. Capps is a good closer who pitched injured last year but will put up solid numbers. Gonzalez is a solid closer but a bigger injury risk than Capps and probably bigger trade bait than Capps.

[Luckskywalker7]

madson
gonzalez
Perez
Lindstrom
Thornton
Capps
The rest are all very similar.

=)

Would you mind helping me out in mine?
viewtopic.php?t=404015

[boredguy]

Gonzalez
Capps
Perez
Madson

[smoovethug]

MGonz
Capps
Perez
Lindstrom
Gregg
Frasor
Madson

[sigriffey]

MGonz
Capps
Madson
Perez
Lindstrom
Frasor
Gregg

[Bloody Sox]

Please rank these prospective closers

MGonz
Perez (after he was named closer yesterday)
Capps
Madson
Lindstrom
Gregg
Frasor

[Johnny Tuttle]

I've got Gonzalez first as the best actual closer.

Madson's second, but he's first is Lidge is actually removed from the picture finally.

viewtopic.php?t=404069